Outlaw Johnny Black

Michael Jai White

Outlaw Johnny Black

Anika Noni Rose

Jessie Lee

Erica Ash

Bessie Lee

Byron Minns

Reverend Percival Fairman

Kevin Chapman

US Marshall Cove

Kym Whitley

Sister Betty

Tommy Davidson

Clancy

Buddy Lewis

Deacon Fry

Glynn Turman

Bullseye Black

Chris Browning

Brett Clayton

Barry Bostwick

Tom Sheally

Gary Anthony Williams

Mayor Williams

Tony Baker

Sherriff Yarbrough

Tyler Bryan

Duke Clayton

Paul Logan

The Bounty Hunter

Randy Couture

Bill Basset

Eme Ikwuakor

Elmer

Jalyn Hall

Young Johnny Black

Donald Cerrone

Crackshot Bob

Jill Scott

Maw Belle

Roger Yuan

Lee

Tomm Voss

Kane

Michael Madsen

Dutch

Josh Barnett

Bobo

Jimmy Walker Jr.

Old Man

Michael Bearden

Teeny (Piano Player)

Paul Sloan

Eddie

Heath Freeman

Jed Clayton

Kyle Rezzarday

Native American Boy

Lauren Albo

Native American Girl

Edwin Modlin II

Deputy

Reggie Currelley

Usher

Robert Allen Mukes

Big Feather

Russell Peters

Big Chief

Peter Sherayko

Cheyenne Mayor

Paul Logan

Bounty Hunter

Robert Goldman

Doc Flemister

Matthew Godbey

Cowboy

Damon Standifer

Ned

Michael Colyar

Barker

Wendy Davis

Vernell

Nicholas Walker

Natural Born Native American

John Marrs

Bo Clayton

Nadia Quezada

Native American

Mariana Cabrera

Native American

Cody Jones

Native American

Raul

Native American

Greg Williams

Church Goer / Staff

Carlos Barbouth

Fair Goer

Cammie Middleton

Fair Goer

Enjunaya Canton

Fair Goer

Travis Lee Eller

Ruff Rider

Rick Groat

Bill Basset's Men

Jerry Bestpitch

Bassett Gang Member

Larry Poole

Tom Sheally's Men

Gary Sievers

Marshall's Men

Troy Dillinger

Town Crier

Waymond Lee

Townspeople

Billie J Bradford

Townspeople

Elena Chin

Townspeople

James Quach

Townspeople

Jarrell Pyro Johnson

Armed Townspeople

Barry McDaniel

Choir Member

Jon Johnson

Saloon Patron

Jay Giannone

Undertaker (uncredited)

Louis Gossett Jr.

Reverend Tharrington (voice) (uncredited)